This discussion has been locked.
You can no longer post new replies to this discussion. If you have a question you can start a new discussion

Copying Files into Traditional Folders

Dear All

When I copy files into a traditional folder, for a few files I get an error saying that the file has no content and cannot be copied. I know an empty file does not need to be copied but the end users wants all his files into a traditional folder. Is there a way to copy files even without content?

Thank you

  • Hi there, 

    Instead of letting users to go with traditional folders, offer them training out of that . That feature is there only for compatibility reasons for some CAD software workability and for some really old software compatibility reasons. For new stuff, you should -never- use traditional folders, or let the users actually use those. 

    Traditional folders work great when you import a folder structure from the Windows to the M-Files, but you should try to get rid of that folder structure ASAP as it does not serve the logic of using M-Files as a powerful search tool. 

    If the end user wants their stuff to traditional folder, it would be good to ask "what for" question at that point. 

    If it's just "because that's how I've always done", then you know you need to give them a training lessons of how things work Slight smile

    And, why would empty files need to be at the document vault? 

  • Thanks for the response. The problem is that the user has thousands of files from windows structured folder wise (100 of folder inside folders inside folder etc.). I have already informed the end user that we should refrain from using traditional folders as it becomes very difficult to give permissions to a set of users after the files have been uploaded. We would have to go to each file and give individual permissions for each user as it does not inherit the parent folder permissions. I have told them 100 times already but the end user is at a very high post and is asking me that "should he transfer his 10000 documents one by one? He even asked me to write a script that will transfer all the documents. Please suggest the best way to copy his 10000 files that have a tree structure into M-Files. 

  • ok thanks.. so from this whole conversation I have understood that in order for me to transfer the files from folders into M-Files. I would need to create a csv file and have metadata in that CSV file for 10000 odd documents. But what metadata can the current files have ? I am a bit confused. what would be there in the CSV file as in like what metadata. Thank you and sorry for the silly question

  • Sorry to barge in at this point.
    I just wonder if you have considered leaving the files in place and use Network Folder Connector to make them visible in M-Files? This way they will get indexed to allow full text searched, if configured correctly you get the path in a special multiline text property, you can browse the structure, and you can promote relevant files from unmanaged objects to M-Files documents and add metadata as required. In most cases it is just a small percentage of existing flles that actually need metadata for current and future activities. As long as you have the search capabilities it is relatively easy to find historic documents when needed, so it is not worth the effort to add metadata to most of those old files.

    Users can still work in the folder environment and add files there if they need to. But you probably want to limit that kind of activity to make sure new files are created as documents in M-Files from start.

  • This seems like a good way forward. Is this a paid connector? and can I have some documentation to implement it. Thanks in advance

  • Included with M-Files Standard, Professional or Enterprise Subscription

  • I just found out that the empty file is a notepad file and the name of the document is the password. The file contains nothing in it. Only the name of the file is the password. Any suggestions?

  • You could create a separate object type for this use: for instance object type Credentials if there are more of these types of passwords to store, with a property called Password and potentially other properties (Notes about the system the password is for and so on). Then you can control the visibility of the credential with the object and property definition permissions.

  • Dear Joonas

    Many thanks for the response. but currently I am just copying them into traditional folders for a couple of months as we are planning to move from perpetual licensing to a subscription licensing. After that I will try out the Network Folder Connector. But just out of curiosity why would M-Files stop me from copying any kind of files. Be it empty or full. Its something that they need to think about. 

  • I wouldn't move such files into M-Files at all but rather plan the vault structure and the migration so that it serves the users best in the future. The password is currently stored as a file because the file system doesn't offer any better ways to store this kind of information. With M-Files you have better ways to do it so I would try to think of the best possible solution before moving any files into the vault rather than trying to replicate the current structure 1:1.

    Of course you may have other considerations such as the project schedule here, I'm just pointing out that people who are used to file folders and their limitations often don't realize that there is a smarter way to work. Slight smile

  • I totally get your point but I cannot do it for 100000 files right now. Disappointed

Reply Children
No Data